Mystic Monk Coffee Scandal

Mystic Monk Coffee Scandal: The Ultimate Guide

The Mystic Monk Coffee scandal garnered significant attention online and raised ethical concerns surrounding coffee brands. It also brought to light the transparency challenges within religious organizations, particularly in the case of the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming. They faced allegations of using funds from their coffee business to acquire a $7.5 million ranch in the Wyoming mountains.

The world of specialty coffee was profoundly disrupted by the emergence of the Mystic Monks Scandal. Mystic Monk Coffee, a seemingly benign coffee brand operated by the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming, faced accusations of deceiving customers and mishandling finances.

This scandal not only sullied the brand’s image but also prompted critical inquiries into the transparency and responsibility of religious organizations.

What Mystic Monks Scandal?

The “Mystic Monks Affair” pertains to a legal dispute involving the Wyoming Carmelite Monks, a Roman Catholic monastic order. In 2006, these monks initiated the sale of coffee under the brand “Mystic Monk Coffee” with the intention of raising funds for the construction of a new monastery.

However, allegations emerged that the monks had mishandled the proceeds from coffee sales. These accusations included diverting funds towards lavish renovations for their existing location instead of progressing toward the new monastery’s construction, as well as using the money for personal expenses.

Furthermore, the monks faced criticism for their aggressive marketing strategies related to their coffee business and for providing inaccurate portrayals of monastic life at their monastery. In response to these concerns, the Roman Catholic Diocese of Cheyenne conducted an inquiry, which revealed financial improprieties on the part of the monks. Consequently, Father Daniel Mary, their immediate superior, resigned from his position.

Who Created Mystic Monk Coffee?

In 2007, the Mystic Monk Coffee brand was established by a group of Catholic monks, famously known as the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming. 

These monks reside in the serene setting of Mount Carmel, Wyoming, and their decision to venture into the roasting and online sale of coffee beans was the result of extensive prayer and deliberation. Their motivation was twofold: to sustain their way of life and support their growing community.

Roasting coffee beans proved to be an excellent choice for them. Their tranquil surroundings allowed them to engage in the roasting process, and a portion of the coffee sales was dedicated to funding their mission.

What set Mystic Monk Coffee apart was the fact that the monks themselves handled the coffee bean roasting. Since its inception, the brand has gained popularity among coffee enthusiasts who value the unique connection to the Carmelite monks and their way of life.

Due to its spiritual origins, Mystic Monk Coffee became a cherished brand, particularly among devoted Catholics who appreciated the opportunity to support the monks in their endeavors.

History Of Mystic Monk Coffee

In 2007, Father Daniel Mary, a Carmelite Monk from St. Clare Monastery in Wyoming, laid the foundation for Mystic Monk Coffee. His vision was to establish a self-sustaining monastery that could provide support for the monastic community. To realize this vision, he embarked on a unique venture: creating his own coffee company.

Founded on the principles of fair trade and a commitment to quality, Mystic Monk Coffee has now become the official coffee of the Carmelite Monastery.

 Over time, it has grown into one of the most renowned specialty coffee brands, offering an array of blends, roasts, and flavors to coffee enthusiasts. In addition to their coffee offerings, they also provide a wide range of merchandise, including mugs, apparel, and various gift items.

Mystic Monk Coffee Scandal Aftermath 

  • As a result of the scandal, Mystic Monk Coffee underwent significant changes in its sourcing and production procedures. The brand adopted a more transparent approach to its operations and established close partnerships with ethical suppliers. 
  • They also made substantial investments in quality control measures to ensure the high quality of their products. The Mystic Monk Coffee scandal served as a wake-up call for the specialty coffee industry. 
  • Both coffee brands and consumers became more vigilant regarding the sourcing and production of their cherished brews, leading to increased demands for transparency and accountability from producers.
  • This incident with Mystic Monk Coffee also serves as a reminder that even seemingly ethical and religious brands can sometimes compromise their values in pursuit of financial gain. 
  • It urges consumers to exercise caution when supporting brands that appear to align with their values. Scandals, although distressing for those involved, can impart valuable lessons to those who pay attention. 
  • Another prevalent type of scandal in the United States is the cheating scandal. Some, such as the Khloe Kardashian and Tristan Thompson cheating scandal, have rocked Hollywood, while others have garnered less attention. Nevertheless, one thing remains certain: scandals, like mistakes, have the potential to shape or tarnish one’s future.


The Mystic Monk Coffee Scandal serves as a poignant reminder of the significant impact that ethical shortcomings can have. While it shed light on the negative aspects of Mystic Monk Coffee, it also acted as a catalyst for positive transformation within the industry. 

Presently, Mystic Monk Coffee is committed to upholding its core values, working diligently to rebuild the confidence of its customers, and reestablishing itself as a symbol of ethical sourcing and unwavering integrity.


What is the Mystic Monks scandal?

The Mystic Monks scandal encompasses a sequence of events involving the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming and their coffee venture, Mystic Monk Coffee.

These monks faced allegations of purchasing a $7.5 million ranch in the Wyoming mountains using funds from their coffee business, all without disclosing this expenditure to their donors.

Who are the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming and what is their mission?

The Carmelite Monks of Wyoming consist of a community of Catholic men who have wholeheartedly committed themselves to a life characterized by prayer, solitude, and selflessness.

Their overarching purpose is to devoutly serve God by means of a life centered on prayer and deep contemplation. Furthermore, they aim to demonstrate their love for Christ through the monastic way of life they lead.

What is Mystic Monk Coffee?

In 2007, the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming established Mystic Monk Coffee, a renowned coffee brand. This brand is distinguished for its top-tier, morally acquired coffee, with a portion of its earnings dedicated to bolstering the monks’ monastery and various philanthropic endeavors.

What were the allegations against the Mystic Monks?

The Mystic Monks faced allegations of deceiving their donors regarding the financial condition of both the monastery and their coffee business. Moreover, they were accused of resorting to unethical methods to sustain the business.

Furthermore, they were implicated in using proceeds from their coffee venture to acquire a $7.5 million ranch in the Wyoming mountains without disclosing this acquisition to their donors.

What was the outcome of the scandal?

As a consequence of the scandal, a settlement was reached, with the monks committing to refund all donations they had received in exchange for commitments related to future business prospects. Additionally, they pledged not to make such commitments in the future.

This scandal garnered significant media coverage and prompted inquiries into the ethical aspects of fundraising methods, as well as the involvement of religious organizations in commercial endeavors.

What changes were implemented by Mystic Monk Coffee following the scandal?

Mystic Monk Coffee undertook comprehensive revisions to its sourcing and production procedures. 

They enhanced transparency in their operations, established close collaborations with ethical suppliers, and made substantial investments in quality control measures to guarantee their products met the most stringent standards.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *